USA Discography Reference · 1953–1961

Frankie Valli, The Four Seasons & The Four Lovers — The Early Years

Every traced pre-December 1961 recording — as The Four Lovers, backing other artists, or solo — before the group's first release as The 4 Seasons

Before they were The 4 Seasons, the group's members recorded and performed under several names — The Four Lovers, Frankie Valley (solo, before he settled on "Valli"), and as uncredited or barely-credited backing vocalists behind other artists. This page brings together every such release traced up to December 1961, when the group first recorded as The 4 Seasons, along with the albums, reissues and various-artist compilations that have since gathered this early material together, and the small number of non-USA pressings and reissues found.

This is dense reference material rather than a simple list — entries are given largely as researched, including the trade-paper citation dates and pressing notes that establish when and how each record appeared.

How to read an entry

Most entries follow the same shape: title(s), any trade-press citation in curly braces, the label and catalogue number, and finally the release date in square brackets — for example, Water boy/Voglio cantare {CB rev 20/02/60; BB rev 15/02/60} CB 111 MV 108 Warwick M 529 [02/60] means a Cash Box review on 20 February 1960 and a Billboard review on 15 February 1960, Warwick catalogue number M 529, released February 1960.

182Releases Traced
4USA Categories
6Countries
1953–2025Years Covered
No entries match your search.
Early Years · 33 releases

USA Chronological Discography, 1953–1961

Frankie Valley — My Mother’s Eyes/The Laugh’s on Me Corona 45-1234 (78 rpm Corona 1234) [03/53] (78 rpm promo My mother’s eyes 1234-A1/The laugh’s on me 1234-AA)
Frankie Valley & The Travelers — Somebody Else Took Her Home/Forgive and Forget {CB rev 29/05/54; BB rev and ad 05/06/54} Mercury 70381-X45 (78 rpm 70381) [05/54] (above was issued on a black and a rarer maroon coloured Mercury label; 78 rpm version 70381 in both shellac and plastic formats. Both tracks recorded at The Fine Recording Studios, NYC with Hugo Peretti and his Orchestra)
4 Lovers — *Apple of My Eye/**Girl in My Dreams {CB rev 28/04/56; BB rev 05/05/56} *BB 62 *MV 80; ** MV 85 RCA Victor 47-6518 45 rpm (78 rpm 20-6518) [20/04/56]
4 Lovers — Please Don’t Leave Me/***Honey Love {CB rev 28/04/56; BB rev 05/05/56} ***MV 82 RCA Victor 47-6519 45 rpm (78 rpm 20-6519) [20/04/56]
4 Lovers — Be Lovey Dovey/Jambalaya {BB and CB revs 08/09/56} RCA Victor 47- 6646 45 rpm (78 rpm 20- 6646) [24/08/56]
4 Lovers — Love Sweet Love (never released; recorded August 10th, 1956 on RCA) (The above track plus another unreleased track “What is this thing called love” (recorded 15/06/56) is featured on the German CD “The Four Lovers” on Bear Family label BCD 15424 [25/04/89])
4 Lovers — “Joyride” LP {BB and CB revs 08/12/56} RCA Victor LPM 1317 [23/11/56] (I want a girl just like the girl that married dear old dad/Such a night /For sentimental reasons/Joyride/This is my tory/Memories of you/It's too soon to know/San Antonio rose/White Christmas/Night train/Cimarron/Lawdy Miss Clawdy)
⁺4 Lovers — “The Four Lovers” EP with tracks:- Diddilly Diddilly Babe/The Stranger/Shake a Hand & Night Train. {BB cited 23/06/56} (with cardboard picture sleeve) RCA Victor EPA 869 [25/05/56]
⁺4 Lovers — “Joyride” EP with tracks:- Memories of You/This Is My Story/For Sentimental Reasons/I Want a Girl Just Like the Girl That Married Dear Old Dad. (with carboard pic slv) RCA Victor EPA 871 [12/56]
4 Lovers — Never Never/Happy Am I {BB and CB revs 29/12/56} RCA Victor 47-6768 45 rpm (78rpm 20-6768) [14/12/56]
4 Lovers (Happy am I/Never never) b/w Homer and Jethro (Mama from the train/I’m my own grandpaw) Promotional EP only RCA DJ-47 [12/56]
4 Lovers — The Stranger/Shake a Hand {BB and CB revs 09/02/57} RCA Victor 6812 [25/01/57]
4 Lovers (Shake a hand/The stranger) b/w Teddi King (Should I ever love again/A ride on a rainbow) Promotional EP only RCA DJ-64 [01/57]
4 Lovers — The Stranger/Night Train (never released) The catalogue no. 6819 reputedly assigned to this intended 4 Lovers’ single came out by Tito Puente with The Versatones “Calypso Blues/Cubana Boy” RCA 47-6819 [02/57] Royal Teens (with Bob Gaudio) Short shorts/Planet rock (original pressing) Power 215 [11/57]
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — Short Shorts/Planet Rock {BB rev 13/01/58; CB rev 18/01/58; RW rev 27/01/58} BB 3 CB 3 MV 5 BB R&B 2 ABC Paramount 9882 [01/58] {Royal Teens (with Gaudio) Short shorts/Planet Rock ri (black or gold 45 rpm pressing) Power 215 [02/62]}
4 Lovers — My Life for Your Love/Pucker Up (78 rpm and 45 rpm regular/stock copies) Epic 5-9255 [24/02/58] (both tracks recorded in October 1957. The ‘A’ side was originally titled “A love for only you” and then changed; black and white label promo exists)
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — Big Name Button/Sham Rock {BB rev 28/04/58; CB rev 03/05/58} CB 59 MV 84 ABC Paramount 9918 [04/58]
Frankie Tyler (= Frankie Valli) — I Go Ape/If You Care {BB cited & CB rev 26/07/58 } Okeh 4-7103 [07/58] (black & white label demo; yellow/black label stock) Royal Teens (with Gaudio) Harvey’s got a girlfriend/Hangin’ around {BB rev 14/07/58; CB rev 19/07/58; CB ad 02/08/58} BB 78 ABC Paramount 9945 [07/58]
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — Open the Door/My Kind of Dream {BB rev 08/09/58; CB rev 08/09/58} ABC Paramount 9955 [09/58]
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — xLeotards/Royal Blue (xmatrix no. 109X) {BB rev 09/02/59; CB cited 31/01/59} Mighty 111 [01/59]
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — xxI’ll Not Be the One (to say goodbye)/Royal Blue (xxmatrix no. 109 ) Mighty111 [02/59]
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — Sittin’ with My Baby/Mad Gass {BB rev 27/04/59} Power 113 [04/59]
Frankie Valle (=Frankie Valli) & The Romans — Come Si Bella (as *The Romans only)/Real (This is real) {CB rev 28/02/59} Cindy C-3012 [03/59] (*The Romans = Tom DeVito, Hank Majewski and Charles Calello) {N.B. “Come si bella” written by Carmen DePalma & Charles Calello copyright 22/10/58; George N Terry (piano ragtime arranger) recorded a piano arrangement of “Come si bella (So nice)” and copyrighted it on Sunno Music # ep 13114 [25/05/59]}
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — Cave Man/Wounded Heart Mighty 112 [03/59]
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — Believe Me/Little Cricket {BB rev 24/08/59; CB rev 05/09/59} BB 26 CB 24 MV 30 Capitol 4261 [08/59]
Frankie Vally (= Frankie Valli) — Please Take a Chance/It May Be Wrong {BB rev 02/11/59;CB rev 28/11/59} Decca 9-30994 [10/59] (Black/silver label regular pressing; pink/black label promo copy with words “Sample copy- not for sale; recorded 29/06/59)
Nickie (= Nick Massi) & The Nite Lites — Tell Me You Care/I’m Lonely {BB rev 26/10/59; CB rev 24/10/59} Brunswick 9-55155 [10/59]
The Hollywood Playboys (vocals Nick Massey) — You Can’t Fool Me Baby/I’m Lonely Rita R-118 [11/59]
The Hollywood Playboys (vocals Nick Massi) — Talk to Audrey/Ding Dong School Is Out {CB rev 02/07/60} Sure S-105 [06/60]
Royal Teens (with Gaudio) — The Moon’s Not Meant for Lovers (Anymore)/Was It a Dream {BB rev 01/02/60; CB rev 06/02/60} CB 101 Capitol 4335 [01/60]
Village Voices (4 Seasons pseudonym) — Too Young to Start/Red Lips (rare black & yellow label) {CB rev 5/61; BB rev 29/05/61} (Later pressings had black, yellow and white label Topix 45-6000 [05/61]
Turner Di Sentri (Bob Gaudio pseudonym) — Ten Million Tears (Theme from “Another Apartment”) /Spanish Lace Theme from “The West Side”) {BB rev 14/08/61; CB rev 29/08/61} Topix 45-6001 [08/61] (mainly instrumental single with Valli, Massi & DeVito back-up vocals where appropriate and Valli epilogue)
Billy Dixon & The Topics (4 Seasons pseudonym) — I Am All Alone/Trance {BB rev 16/10/61} Topix 45-6002 [10/61] {See The 4 Seasons/Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons USA Discography from 12/61 onwards for use of the titles The Four Seasons/Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons}
Early Years · 7 releases

USA Reissue, Bootleg & Unofficial Releases

Billy Dixon and The Topics — Trance/I Am All Alone (with black or coloured vinyl as 778 below) Seasons 4 Ever label 777 [02-03/74]
Frankie Tyler — I Go Ape/If You Care (in black and different coloured vinyl – green, yellow, blue, red and white) Seasons 4 Ever 778 [02-03/74]
Frankie Valle & The Romans — Come Si Bella/Real (This is real) limited ri with Cindy printed in plain silver lettering unlike orig. red & silver Cindy C-3012 [1974]
The Four Lovers — Please Take a Chance/It May Be Wrong Decca 9-30994 [1975] (Black/silver label regular; pink/black label without the words “Sample copy - not for sale on label)
The 4 Lovers — “Joyride” LP {Limited Collectors’ Edition} RCA LP 7131 [01/77]
Frankie Valley — My Mother’s Eyes/The Laugh’s on Me {black/other vinyl colours} Magic Carpet 503 [1979]
4 Lovers — Pucker Up/My Life for Your Love {in different vinyl colours - red, gold, black) Magic Carpet 504 [1979]
Early Years · 38 releases

USA Official Reissue Releases

The Four Lovers CD (Lost Nite Collectors’ Collection) Lost Nite Records LN CD 1039 [1989] (Tracks: Girl in my dreams/Apple of my eye/Honey love/Please don’t leave me/Be lovey dovey/Jambalaya/Happy am I/Never never/Diddilly diddilly babe/Pucker up/My life for your love/The stranger/Cimarron/It’s too soon to know/Memories of you/San Antonio rose/For sentimental reasons/Such a night/This is my story/White Christmas/Please take a chance/It may be wrong)
4 Lovers The Four Lovers: 1956 CD-distribution only licence Rhino R2-90142 [07/93] {This is the1989 Germany Bear Family CD release (see later on) assigned a Rhino distribution number only with a few alternative takes included and previously unissued original RCA Victor recordings}
The Four Lovers CD The Very Best Of The Four Lovers Taragon TGN 1107.2 [21/04/09] {This CD was initially scheduled for release on 29/09/06 but delayed for three years until 2009 release}. (You’re the apple of my eye/The girl in my dreams/Please don’t leave me/Honey love/Be lovey dovey/Jambalaya/Happy am I/Never never/Shake a hand/The stranger/Diddilly diddilly babe/Night train/Love, sweet love/What is this thing called love)
USA Various Artists 45 rpm vinyl records Pre-December 1961 With Backing Vocals By The “Pre-4 Seasons” (Valli/Massi/DeVito/Gaudio)
Lorry Raine *The flame of love/*All my love (*4 Lovers backing vocals) Advance Records 3015 [1957]
Danny & The Juniors Rock and roll is here to stay (Valli only sings on ‘A’ side track)/Schoolboy romance {BB rev 03/02/58; CB rev 08/02/58} (BB 19 CB 22 MV 23) ABC 9888 [01/58]
The Delicates The Johnny bunny/My first date (Valli/DeVito/Massi backing) Tender 818 [12/58]
Virgil Holmes Walking alone/Ghost train (Pre-4 Seasons backup) Atlantic 2103 [05/61]
Lenny O’Henry and the Short Stories Cheated heart/Billy the continental kid (Pre-4 Seasons backing) {CB rev 27/05/61; BB rev 29/05/61} ABC Paramount 10222 [05/61]
Miss Frankie Nolan I still care (Pre-4 Seasons backup)/Summer all year round ABC Paramount 10231 [06/61]
Matthew Reid Jane/Why start (Pre-4 Seasons backup) {BB rev 18/11/61; CB rev 18/11/61} ABC Paramount 45-1025 [10/61]
Hedy, Freddie and Mee Too Spinaround/Playing hard to get (Pre-4 Seasons backup) Pop-Side PS-1 [10/61]
Ginny Arnell No one cares/Tribute to you (Pre-4 Seasons backup) Warwick M 671 [10/61]
Bob Crewe Another day/*Come to me (Pre-4 Seasons backup) ABC 45-10273 [11/61]
Hal-Miller & The Rays (Valli/DeVito/Massi/Gaudio backing vocals) An angel cried/Faith, hope and dreams {BB rev 20/11/61; CB rev 02/12/61} } (CB 135) Topix 45-6003 [11/61]
Danny & The Juniors Twistin’ all night long (Valli only sings on ‘A’ side)/Some kind of nut {BB rev 27/11/61; CB rev 02/12/61} (BB 68 CB 106 MV 75) Swan 4092 [11/61]
Possibly? Pre-4 Seasons Backing Vocals
Freddie Cannon The urge/Jump over (Valli/DeVito/Massi/Gaudio backing?){BB rev 11/04/60 and ad 18/04/60} BB 60 CB 76 MV 80 Swan 4053 [04/60]
Kevin McQuinn Every step of the way/Keep me on your mind {BB &CB revs 11/11/61} (MV 122) Diamond 101 [10/61]
Lenny O’Henry The touch of you/Goin’ to a party ABC Paramount 10272 [11/61]
Pre-4 Seasons Various Non-USA Reissues
4 Lovers Joyride ri LP Australia Rebel 1009 [1983]
⁺Rockin’ Xmas E.P. 45 rpm (4 Lovers’ track “White Christmas” ) Sweden Jan-Jul EP 1986-2 [1986]
Between 4 Lovers And 4 Seasons LP Sweden Host 100 label Valli 1 [10/88] {4 Lovers – Pucker up/My life for your love; Frankie Tyler – I go ape/If you care; Frankie Vally – It may be wrong; Frankey Valley – Forgive and forget; The Rays – Are you happy now?/Bright brown eyes; Van Trevor – A fling of the past/C’mon baby; Four Kings – One night; The Topics – Trance/Lost lullabye/I am all alone}
The Four Lovers: 1956 (1st one on CD) {RC No. 131 rev [07/89]} Germany Bear Family BCD 15424 [25/04/89] {The girl in my dreams-take 8 /Diddilly diddilly babe-take 6/Shake a hand-take 4/Honey love-take 2/Please don't leave me-take 2/You're the apple of my eye-take 7/The stranger-take 4/White Christmas-take 2/It's too soon to know-take 1/2 /San Antonio rose-take 2/Night train-take 6/Cimarron-take 6/Lawdy Miss Clawdy-take 2/ What is a thing called love-take 2/Joyride-take 2/Such a night-take 5 /This is my story-take 1/For sentimental reasons take 2/3/I want a girl just like the girl that married dear old dad-take 3/Memories of you-take 3/Jambalaya-take 8/Be lovey dovey-take 4/Love sweet love-take 5/Happy am I-take 7/Never never-take 8/For sentimental reasons-take 1/White Christmas-take 1/The girl in my dreams-take 4/Diddilly diddilly babe-take 8/Such a night-take 1/Honey love-take 1}
Frankie Valli and The 4 Seasons -The Fantastic First Years CD Denmark Sparkletone SP 99005 [08/95] {My mother’s eyes/The laugh’s on me (Frankie valley);Somebody else took her home/Forgive and forget (Frankie Valley & The Travelers); I go ape/If you care (Frankie Tyler); My life for your love/Pucker Up (4 Lovers); Come si bella/Real (This real) Frankie Valle & The Romans; Please take a chance/It may be wrong (Frankie Vally); *I still care/All year round (Miss Frankie Nolan);Trance/I am all alone (Billy Dixon & The Topics); An angel cried (*Hal Miller & The Rays); Betty Jean/More lovin’, less talkin’ (*Johnny Halo); Little pony (*Alex Alda); Lost lullabye (Billy Dixon & The Topics); Big brown eyes (*The Rays); The girl in my dreams (The Topics); Pollyanna (*John Corey); A fling of the past/C’mon now baby (*Van Trevor); No lies (*The Kokomas); Stood up/Little Lana (*Larry Lee); One night/Lonely lovers (*The Four Kings); What about me (*Jonathan Marcus);You’re the apple of my eye/Please don’t leave me (4 Lovers); Things go better with Coke/Cousin Brucie Go Go Theme (4 Seasons)} Known 4 Seasons backing vocals to these artists (*)
This Is My Story (Frankie Valli) CD (mono) UK Jasmine Records JASCD 565 [09/10/10] {40XFile, MP3, 320 kbps [10/07/12]} {My mother’s eyes/The laugh’s on me/Somebody else took her home/Forgive and forget/Girl in my dreams/You’re the apple of my eye/Honey love/Please don’t leave me/Jambalaya/Be lovey dovey/Happy am I/Never never/Shake a hand/The stranger/Night train/Didilly didilly babe/White Christmas/It’s too soon to know/San Antonio Rose/Cimarron/Lawdy Miss Clawdy/Joy Ride/Such a night/This is my story/I love you for sentimental reasons/I want a girl just like the girl that married dear old dad/Memories of you/What is this thing called love/Love sweet love/You’re the apple of my eye (live)/Please don’t leave me (live)/Pucker up/My life for your love/I go ape/If you care/Please take a chance/It may be wrong/Come si bella/Real (this is real)/An angel cried}
Roots Of The Four Seasons - The Doo Wop Years CD UK Go Entertainment label GO2CD7079 [09/11] {CD1: My mother’s eyes/The laugh’s on me (Frankie Valley);Somebody else took her home/Forgive and forget (Frankie Valley and the Travelers); You’re the apple of my eye/The girl in my dreams/Honey love/Please don’t leave me/Jambalaya/Never Never/Shake a hand/Be lovey dovey/The stranger/Pucker up/Lawdy Miss Clawdy/Such a night/Memories f you (The Four Lovers). CD2: Night train/I want a girl just like the girl that married dear old dad/Diddilly diddilly babe/I love you for sentimental reasons/My life for your love/This is my story/ (The Four Lovers); Short shorts/Believe me (The Royal Teens);I go ape/If you care (Frankie Tyler); Come si bella/Real This is real (Frankie Valle & The Romans); Please take a chance/It may be wrong (Frankie Vally); I am all alone/Trance/Lost lullabye (Billy Dixon & The Topics); An angel cried (Hal Miller and The Rays)}
Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons - The Anthology CD UK One Way Music DAY2CD193 [18/02/13] {All the tracks on the 1962 “Sherry and 11 Others” album plus Bermuda, Spanish Lace, I’ve cried before, Connie-O and Santa Claus is comin’ to town are included in this 2 CD set. Rest of the tracks are Come si bella/Real (This is real)/I go ape/if you care/My mother’s eyes/The laugh’s on me/Somebody else took her home/Forgive and forget/Please take a chance/It may be wrong/An angel cried/More lovin’, less talkin’/Red lips/I am all alone/Trance/Never never/Please don’t leave me/It’s too soon to know/Night train/I want a girl (just like the girl that married dear old dad)/My life for your love/The stranger/Honey love/Lawdy Miss Clawdy/This is my story/San Antonio rose/I love you for sentimental reasons/You’re the apple of my eye/Such a night/ Joyride/Cimarron/Jambalaya/Pucker up}
The 4 Seasons - Jersey Boys For Always CD The Netherlands IMC Music CDRMB 74185/ Remember label 1070435 [04/04/13] {Similar tracks to others viz. entire Vee-Jay “Sherry” LP plus “I’ve cried before” and “Connie-O”; Gone, Epic and Cindy label tracks; Topix 6000 tracks (I am all alone/Trance) plus 4 Lovers’ RCA recordings (Lawdy Miss Clawdy/Please don’t leave me/White Christmas/Night train/You’re the apple of my eye}
The Four Lovers: 1956 (ri) original Germany non-EU import edition Bear Family OTCD 3295 [31/08/13]
The 4 Seasons Valli’s Peaks – 1962: The Incredible First Year CD UK Jasmine Records JASCD 287 [10/01/14] {The tracks “Bermuda” and “Spanish Lace” are to be found on this CD plus all original “Sherry” and “Seasons Greetings” album tracks, I’ve cried before, Connie-O, Walk like a man and Lucky ladybug}
The Boys From Jersey: A Tribute To The Four Seasons And The Jersey Boys CD UK CD Delta Music Leisure Group CD 6875 [16/06/14] {First 16 tracks by a cover group The Boys From Jersey {Working my way back to you/Who loves you/Walk like a man/Stay/Sherry/Rag doll/My eyes adored you/Fallen angel/December 1963 (Oh what a night)/Dawn/C’mon Marianne/Can’t take my eyes off you/By bye baby (baby, goodbye)/Big man in town/Big girls don’t cry/Beggin’. The remaining 15 tracks are by the authentic Frankie Valli and the 4 Seasons{My mother’s eyes (1953 version)/You’re the apple of my eye (4 Lovers)/I go ape/Short shorts (Royal Teens)/Trance/An angel cried (Hal Miller)/Oh Carol/Yes sir, that’s my baby/I can’t give you anything but love/Peanuts/Jambalaya/Lawdy Miss Clawdy/Girl in my dreams (4 Seasons)/Big girls don’t cry/Sherry}
The Four Seasons And The Boys From Jersey “Jersey Boys” (ri ) CD UK Simply Music Classics label S 91029 [21/10/16] {Tracks as per the Delta Music CD except one version of tracks “Sherry” and “Big Girls Don’t Cry” are missing}
Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons Jersey Cats: 1956-1962 Recordings CD Spain Hoodoo Records HOO 263504 [15/12/14] {Sherry/Big girls don’t cry/La dee dah/Oh Carol/Never on a Sunday/Peanuts/Santa Claus is comin’ to town/Teardrops/Apple of my eye/Walk like a man/Come si bella/If you care/I can’t give you anything but love/Connie-O/Forgive and forget/Real (This is real)/Please don’t leave me/Bermuda/Yes sir, that’s my baby/I go ape/I want a girl just like the girl that married dear old dad/Lawdy Miss Clawdy/I’ve cried before/Spanish Lace/Honey love/Dawn(Go away)/Pucker up}
Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons Jersey Cats: 1956-1962 Recordings CD {RC No. 431 rev [03/15]} Spain non-EU import edition Hoodoo OTCD 4353 [04/03/15]
Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons Jersey Cats: 1956-1962 Recordings vinyl LP Spain Wax-Time Records 772098 [16/10/15] (Sherry/Big girls don’t cry/La dee dah/Oh Carol/Never on a Sunday/Peanuts/Santa Claus is comin’ to town/Teardrops/Apple of my eye/Walk like a man/I can’t give you anything but love/Connie-O/Yes sir that’s my baby/I’ve cried before/Spanish lace/Dawn). {Vinyl LP version only released with *16 tracks}
The 4 Lovers Joyride (ri) original CD Japan Oldays ODR 6351 [15/03/17] {I want a girl just like the girl that married dear old dad/Such a night/For sentimental reasons/Joyride/This is my story/Memories of you/It's too soon to know/San Antonio rose/White Christmas/Night train/Cimarron/Lawdy Miss Clawdy/Apple of my eye/Diddilly diddilly babe/Girl in my dreams/Honey love/Please don’t leave me/Jambalaya/Be lovey dovey/Happy am I/Never never/Shake a hand/The stranger}
The 4 Seasons - Jersey Boys 4 Ever vinyl LP vinyl {RC No. 471 rev [10/17]} The Netherlands Vinyl Passion label VP 90030 [13/10/17] {Tracks: Spanish lace, Bermuda, Come si bella, This is real plus the Sherry album tracks and I’ve cried before}
Frankie Valli: The Early Years 1953-1959 RC No. 494 cited [07/19]} UK/Europe Greyscale GSGZ 178 [26/06/19] {Tracks on this two CD set are identical to the UK Jasmine “This Is My Story (Frankie Valli)” 2010 release above}
Frankie Valli And The Four Seasons – Origins And Early Years 1953 – 62 CD UK Acrobat ADDCD 3411 [04/03/22] {This two CD set of 58 tracks contains all 4 Lovers RCA/Epic plus Corona, Mercury, Cindy and Decca recordings. In addition “Sherry and 11 Others” LP tracks plus I’ve cried before, Connie-O, Santa Claus is comin’ to town, Christmas Tears and the Merry Christmas medley (We wish you a merry Christmas/Hark the herald angels sing/It came upon a midnight clear) from the “Seasons Greetings” album. Three Topix label tracks Red Lips, I am all alone and Trance are included. Finally 4 Seasons backing vocals are present on Hal Miller and the Rays “An angel cried” (Topix 6003) and Johnny Halo’s “More lovin’, Less talkin’” on Topix 6005} Interesting non-USA 4 Lovers Official Releases
Early Years · 88 releases

Various-Artists USA CDs / LPs / Cassettes Containing a Pre-December 1961 Track

Starring Frankie Valli LP ( Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” & “This is real”) Premier PM (mono)/PS (stereo) 9052 [1964]
The 4 Seasons/Johnny Rivers/Neil Sedaka/The J Brothers LP (“This is real” and “Coma si bella” ) Design DLP 185 (mono)/SDLP 185 stereo) [11/64]
Shindig With The Stars Volume 2 LP {cited as 4 Seasons “Coma si bella” and “Real (This is real)”}Wyncote W 9070 (mono)/SW 9070 (stereo) [12/64]
At The Hop Featuring The 4 Seasons LP (“Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Coronet C-244 (mono)/CXS- 244 (stereo) [1964] (Alternative title “The 4 Seasons Featuring Charlie Francis, Barbara Brown and The Buggs – At The Hop” ) Shindig “This is Real” LP (cited as 4 Seasons) Stereo Spectrum–Stereo Spotlight Series Design DLP 190 (mono)/SDLP 190 (stereo) [01/65]
Shindig Hullabaloo Spectacular LP (4 Seasons “Comme si bella” & “This is real”) Gladwynne GL 2004 (mono)/GLS 2004 (stereo) [1965]
Shindig LP (ri of DLP/SDLP 190) {4 Seasons “This is real”} International Award Series AK 258 (mono)/AKS 258 (stereo) [1965]
Shindig LP (4 Seasons “This is for real”} (= SDLP 190-A) Showcase Records CPR-9011-A [1965]
All Star Shindig LP (Four Seasons sing “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Spinorama M-154(mono)/ S-54 (stereo) [1965]
Hullabaloo Au-Go-Go LP (4 Seasons sing “Coma si bella”) Design DLP-211/SDLP-211 [1965]
Todays Scene LP (4 Seasons “Coma si bella”) Showcase Records SH-1506 [1965]
Las Vegas Winners (Stars of Las Vegas) LP { Seasons “Comma si bella” & “This is real”} Spinorama M-165(mono)/S-165 (stereo) [1966]
The Young Rascals LP {Starring The 4 Seasons, The Buggs & Johnny Rivers} “Comma si bella” and “This is real” Coronet CX-283/CXS-283 [1966]
Discotheque LP (4 Seasons “Comma si bella” & “This is real”) Premier K-61-1 [1966]
20 Dynamic Superstars Turn Back The Hands of Time (4 Seasons “This is real”) UK LP Ember EMB 3414 [1973] and UK ri on CD Legends LECD023 [1990/1991]; also South Africa LP RPM label RPM 1168 [1973]
Candlelite Music Treasury Series #113 Proudly Presents Magic Moments 4 Lovers “Apple of my eye”) RCA Special Products DPL2-0157 [1975]
Golden Greats of the 60’s 8-track cartridge (4 Seasons “Come si bella”) Altone 114 [>1975/70’s]
A Salute To Rock n’ Roll Volume 1 LP (4 Lovers featuring Frankie Valli “Honey love”) Festival FR 1006A [1976] (Alternative title with different album sleeve “Jim Pewter’s 10th Anniversary Salute To Rock N’ Roll {under Four Lovers, Frankie Valli} Festival Records Distribution, Inc FR 1006 [1976])
Paul Simon Plus LP (Frankie Valli & 4 Seasons “Comme si bella” & “This is real”) USA and Scandinavia MCP records 8027 [1976]; Spain Carnaby CPS 9480 [1976]
Rock ‘N’ Roll Superstars LP {Frankie Valli “Come si bella”&“This is real”} France RCA ML 21015 [1976]
Superstars LP (Frankie Valli “This is real” & “Comme si bella”) France Disc’AZ/locomotive 73437/38/39 [1977]
The Best of the 1950’s Rock & Roll Revival USA LP (Frankie Valley and The Travelers “Somebody else took her home” on record #8819) Candlelite Music Label nos 8818-8820 [1977]
20 Exitos Originales LP (Frankie Valli “This is real” and “Comme si bella”) Spain Puzzle MPL-102 [1978]
Paul Simon Plus LP (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” & “This is real”) Brazil Crazy Cat label CC 15.005 [1978] blue or red/orange LP label; Greece LP (Frankie Valli & Four Seasons “Comme si bella” & “This is real”) Music - Box MB/SMB 15015 [1978] and Greece ri LP Music-Box International SMB 15015 [1989]
Golden 60’s LP (Frankie Valli & 4 Seasons “This is real” and “Come si bella”) Belgium Vogue VK79 [1978]
Paul Simon Plus LP (Frankie Valli & 4 Seasons “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Denmark LSM Records LSLP 3026; musicassette LSMC 3016 [1979]; UK LSM Records 3016 [1979]
Rock Generation Vol 1 LP (Frankie Valli & Four Seasons “Comme si bella” & “This is real”) Denmark LSM Records LSLP 3022 [1979]; France Disques Esperance ESP 155 567 [1979]; Venezuela Corpodisco/MCP Records LPM 8112 [1979]
20 Golden Pieces Of The 50’s & 60’s LP (4 Seasons “This is real”) UK Bulldog Records BDL 2008 [1979]; Australia 7 Records MLR 341 [1979] and Spain Discophon M-6122 [1981]
Originals Superstars LP (Frankie Valli “This is real” & “Comme si bella”) France Euromusic COF 17 [1980]
Paul Simon and Friends – While I Dream LP Frankie Valli tracks “Comme si bella” and “This is real” Sunburst Records, Inc. A..G. 8207 9 [1982]
Dedication Vol 8 LP (Frankie Valli & 4 Seasons “This is real and “Comme si bella”) Spain Alligator Records 50.3011 [1983]
Super Pop Festival LP (Frankie Valli track “Come si bella”) Germany Capriole 460428 [1983]
Boppin’ Buick Unofficial LP (4 Lovers “Diddilly diddilly babe”) Europe label unknown #1959 [1985] (Above also on CD pressing from Europe on Scooter label 062 [1999])
60’s Hits Hits Hits CD (4 Seasons “This is real”) UK Wisepack WPCD 008 [1988]
Rock n’ Roll Party – Volume 2: The Late 50’s CD (4 Lovers “Apple of my eye”, “Girl in my dreams” and” My memories of you”) RCA 9758-2-R [14/11/89]
Roy Orbison, Paul Simon and Friends CD Germany & Switzerland (Frankie Valli “This is real” and “Comme si bella”) Fortune Vivo/Imtrat label imt-700.042 [1988]; Germany musicassette Vivo 700.042 [1988] and Germany ri Fortune CD 3029 [1989]
Paul Simon and Friends CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) UK Object Enterprises label ONN74 [1990]; The Netherlands Arc Records MEC 949039 [1990] and on Dutch Royal Classics/Collection RC 88112 [1991] with Royal Classics ri [01/93]
Jukebox Hits of 1956 Vol. 4 (4 Lovers “Such a night”) CD Israel Jukebox (11) 1356 [1992]
Hitriders Vol. 5 CD (4 Lovers “The girl in my dreams” {1957}) Belgium Ariola Express 290.936 [1992]
24 Baladas Nostalgicas CD (4 Seasons “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Spain Happy CDH-5501-S [1992]
Paul Simon and Friends CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Germany Cosmos 5441263 [1993] and WZ Tontrager Vertriebs GmbH/Legends WZ 90136 [1993]
Paul Simon and Friends: Play Me A Sad Song CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) UK Pilz label PILZ 448227-2/musicassette 448227-4 [1993]
Paul Simon and Friends-The Mejor Musica CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Spain CD 50525 [1994] Paul Simon Plus CD (Frankie Valli and 4 Seasons “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Javelin Promotions Inc., JAVCD141 [1994]; Israel (as Frankie Valli) Javelin HADCD 141 [1994]
Paul Simon – Peaceland CD {Featuring Neil Sedaka and Frankie Valli} CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella and “This is real”); Europe Dog ‘N’ Roll label DNR 065/DNR 065S [1994]
Great Sounds of the 50’s and 60’s CD (4 Seasons “This is real”) UK Fat Boy 195 [1994]
RockJul I Flexiland CD (4 Lovers “White Christmas” ) Denmark Rockwool A/S no # [1994]
Bare Cool Rock CD (4 Lovers “You’re the apple of my eye”) Denmark Rockwool A/S no # [1995] Pure Rock ‘A’Billy Volume 4 LP (4 Lovers “Diddilly diddilly babe”) Spain Club Records PRLP-004 [1995]
Doo-Wop Groups and Crooners: 20 Great Tracks CD (“This is real” Frankie Valli) UK Javelin CWN CD 2019 [1996]; ri UK CWNCD 2019 [13/07/99]
That’s Fats: A Tribute to Fats Domino CD (4 Lovers “Please don’t leave me”) EMI 72438 37356-2-4; UK EMI/Imperial 7243 8 52697-2-1 [02/04/96]
Paul Simon and Friends: Play Me A Sad Song CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Europe Razmataz label RZ 4039 [1996]
Paul Simon and Friends: Play Me A Sad Song CD (Frankie Valley “This is real” & “Comme si bella”) Portugal Altaya/Javelin RB060 [1997]
Paul Simon and Friends: Play Me A Sad Song CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) Spain Altaya label RA 060 [1998]
Rockin’ Is Not Our Business CD (4 Lovers The Girl in My Dreams) UK Westside WESA 830 [18/08/98]
The Official American Bandstand Library Of Rock & Roll CD (Royal Teens “Short shorts” Universal Music Special Markets 314564973-2; EMI-Capitol Music Special Markets 72435-27128-2-8/72435-22537-2-1 ; BMG Special Products DRC 12478/12479; Sony Music Special Products A32505/A32506; Warner Special Products OPCD 1871 [1999]
Paul Simon and Friends CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella” and “This is real”) France Emporio/MCI labels [21/08/99]
Stars Of The 60’s CD (Frankie Valli “Comme si bella) Australia Midas Music MIDCD 027 [1999]
Rock ‘N’ Roll Graffiti CD (Frankie Valli “This is real”) UK Newsound 2000 NSTBX 406 [2001]
Doo Wop Album CD {orig. title “Coming On Strong”} (Frankie Valli “This is real”) UK Newsound 2000 label NSCD 004 [2001]
The Best Of Doo Wop CD (4 Seasons “This is real”) USA and Canada Direct Source Special Products DWT 14462 [2001]
Rock ‘N’ Roll Heaven Vols 1-4 (Discs #178-181) CD (Disc 2 Vol 2 “Good Rocking Tonight” Frankie Valli track “This is real”) UK New Sound label Newsound NST 179 [2002]
The Rock ‘N’ Roll Years CD ( Frankie Valli “This is real”) UK Newsound NSTBX 406V [2002]
Sentimental Journey Vol. 3: Last Train to San Fernando CD (The 4 Lovers “Night Train”) Germany Bear Family Records BCD 16443AR [12/11/02]
Doo-Wop Sh’Bam CD (4 Seasons “This is real”) Europe Forever Gold FG 166 [2003]
Before They Were Stars Volume (Folge) 2 CD Venezuela Concert Products CP 1313 [2003] (Frankie Tyler “If you care”, Billy Dixon and The Topics “I am all alone” and 4 Lovers “Pucker up”)
Real 50’s: The Big Beat CD (4 Lovers “Apple Of My Eye”) Germany BMG Special Prdcts 48134 [30/03/04] Rarest White Groups According To Kreiter Vo1ume 1 CD (4 Lovers “My life for your love”) CD Freddie Records 1001 [2003]
A Novelty Christmas CD (4 Lovers “White Christmas”) Venezuela Silly Records XMAS 1225 [2004]
Doo-Wop Groups and Crooners: 20 Great Tracks CD (ri) “This is real” by Frankie Valli) EU HHO CWNCD 2019 [2005]
Rock n’ Roll Hits Volume 1 UK Daily Express newspaper (26/2/05) {Frankie Valli “This is real} Free CD promo Deceptive label TS047 [26/02/05]
Rock ‘n’ Roll (See ya later alligator, in a while crocodile) CD {The Four Lovers featuring Frankie Valli “The girl in my dreams”} Europe Dynamic label DYN 3919 [2007]
Rockabilly Race – 25 Pure Rockabilly Tracks Vol 2 CD (4 Lovers “Diddilly diddilly babe”) Spain Rockabilly Race RAB02 [2007]; ri Sleazy Records RAB02 [2011]
Sound of the City: New York Area Doo-Wop 1956-1966 CD (4 Lovers “Apple of my eye” and ”Girl in my dreams”; Royal Teens “Believe me”) Time Life Music M19365DIGI/Rhino Custom Products OPCD 8103 [24/07/07]
The Golden Age of Rock N’ Roll Volume 11: Hot Hits From 1954 – 1963 CD (4 Lovers “You’re the apple of my eye”) UK Ace CDCHD 1200 [28/08/07]
Talkin’ About Love CD (4 Lovers “Shake a hand”) Switzerland Pan American Recordings P-A-R 1956037 [2008]
R-R-Real Rock & Roll #9,#9,#9:The R-R-Real Rock & Roll Smackdown, Garage Rock Vs. Doo-Wop CDr, album promo (The Four Lovers “You’re the apple of my eye”) Sweden Teenage Wasteland Records TWL 009/WFMU no # [2009]
Four By Four Classic Vocal Groups Of The 50’s CD {4 Lovers “(You’re the) Apple of my eye” and “Girl in my dreams”} UK Acrobat ADDCD 3071 [2011]
Train Songs (200 Great Songs About Heroes, Hobos and Freight Trains) CD (4 Lovers “Night train”) Germany The Intense Media/Documents 233207 [18/05/12]
High School Rock–Teenage Bop CD (Frankie Tyler “If you care”) Germany Documents DO 600123 [25/11/13]
Otis Blackwell – The Songs & Recordings of Otis Blackwell 1952-1962 CD (4 Lovers “You’re the apple of my eye”) UK Acrobat ADDCD 3229 [2013]
Super Rare Teenage Rock N’Roll Originals CD (Frankie Tyler “I go ape”) Germany Documents DO 600146 [21/04/14]
I Dig ‘Em All – Swan Records Story 1957-1962 CD (Freddie Cannon’s “Twistin’ all night long” features Frankie Valli on vocals) UK One Day Music DAY 2CD 254 [15/07/14]
All Time Classics Of The 50’s and 60’s CD (4 Seasons “This is real”) UK Legends LECD 023 [26/10/14]
Let It Rock (R n’ R 60th Anniversary) CD (4 Lovers “Honey love”) Japan SMJI (Sony Music Japan International) SICP 4479 [4/06/15]
The First Misses CD (4 Seasons “Spanish Lace”) Europe One Day Music DAY3CD089 [2014]
Apprenez A Danser Le Rock 30xFile, MP3 320 kbps (4 Lovers “Be lovey dovey”) France BNF Collection no # [18/12/15]
Big City Christmas CD (4 Lovers “White Christmas –Take1”) Germany Bear Family BCD 17509 [18/11/16]
The Songs And Recordings Of Otis Blackwell 1952-1962 CD (4 Lovers “You’re the apple of my eye”) UK Acrobat Music ADDCD3229 [2018]
Fend Off Impressiveness (Lonesome For A Letter) CD (4 Lovers “Please don’t leave me”) Ireland Anatomical Records ACCD058 [10/21]
Rhythm & Blues Goes Rock & Roll Volume 3: Dance Girl Dance CD (4 Lovers “Lawdy Miss Clawdy”) Ireland and Europe Anatomical Records ACCD103 [24/06/22] (See separately The Royal Teens discography for releases associated with Bob Gaudio)
San Antonio Rose CD (4 Lovers “San Antonio Rose”) UK Jasmine Records JASMCS 2847 [19/10/25]
International Releases

Non-USA Early Years Releases

Vinyl, LPs and CDs featuring pre-December 1961 material, released outside the USA. Grouped by country — click a country to open it.

Canada6 releases
You’re the apple of my eye/Girl of my dreams RCA Victor 47-6518 45rpm (20-6518 78rpm) [1956] (Demo/record prevue has black & white label; *regular pressing has blue and silver label)
Honey Love/Please don’t leave me RCA Victor 47-6519 45rpm (20-6519 78rpm) [1956] (Demo/record prevue 45 rpm has black & white label; *regular)
Jamabalaya/Be lovey dovey RCA Victor 47-6646 45rpm (20-6646 78rpm) [1956] (Demo/record prevue 45 rpm has black & white label; *regular)
“⁺The Four Lovers” EP with PS same as USA copy but with blue & silver label RCA Victor EPA 869 [1956] (Tracks as per USA copy)
“⁺Joyride” EP with PS same as USA copy but with blue & silver label RCA Victor EPA 871 [1956] (Tracks as per USA copy)
Joyride vinyl LP RCA Victor LPM 1317 [1956]
Chile3 releases
Never never/The stranger plus 2 tracks by The Blenders 7" 45 rpm EP RCA Victor CME 114 [1957]
You’re the apple of my eye/The girl of my dreams plus 2 tracks by The Ames Brothers 7” 45 rpm EP RCA CME 132 [1957]
“Joyride“ LP (black & white cover; green RCA label; same photo as per USA album LP) 10” 33⅓ rpm disc with only 10 tracks - It’s too soon to know and San Antonio Rose are excluded RCA Victor CML 3023 [1956]
France1 release
Rock and Roll No. 5 (The Four Lovers) 7" 45 rpm EP (Jambalaya/Lovey dovey/You’re the apple of my eye/Honey love) RCA 75.350 [1956]
Germany4 releases
Jambalaya/Lovey Dovey 7" 45rpm RCA 47-6646 [1956]
The Four Lovers” EP (same tracks/notes as USA copy but no ads on back of sleeve) RCA EPA-869 [1956]
“⁺Joyride” EP (same tracks/notes as USA copy but no ads on back of sleeve) RCA EPA-871 [1957]
“⁺Joyride” LP (same tracks and sleeve notes as US album but no ads on back of sleeve) RCA LPM-1317-C [1956]
India1 release
Night train/The stranger 45rpm Warner Brothers 4120 [1957] My life for your love/Pucker up 45rpm Epic 9255 (unconfirmed)
Norway1 release
Jambalaya/Lovey dovey 10" shellac 78rpm 20-6646 [1956]
Researched by George A. Ingram, with contributions from Ray Nichol, Tom Cramlington, Ken Charmer, Frank Rovello, John Hornsby, Charles Alexander, Russ McLelland, Jose Sanchez, George Juba, Mike Miller and Paul Urbahns, plus Discogs.com and 45cat.com. Revised, corrected and updated by George A. Ingram, September 2026.